Beyond the Game: Response to Vikings’ kicker debacle highlights social media flaws
January 20, 2016
Imagine you’re a placekicker for an NFL team, you have played only seven times in a 60+ minute game, and the fate of your team’s entire season relies on you converting a go-ahead field goal (in the third coldest game in league history). Minnesota Vikings kicker Blair Walsh faced that exact situation.
With 25 seconds left in the National Football Conference Wild Card game against the former NFC champion Seattle Seahawks, Walsh missed a chip shot 27-yard field goal, crushing the Vikings’ hopes of reaching the Super Bowl. To nobody’s surprise, “fans” immediately took to social media, dishing out death threats, mocking the “simplicity” of his job and blaming the special teams player for the demise of the season.
But, let’s keep a few facts in mind: Walsh scored all of the Vikings’ points that game, scoring on each of his three field goal attempts. He made the most field goals out of all placekickers in the 2015-2016 regular season. And he finished with an 87% completion percentage, ranking 14th out of all kickers. Yet, when the time comes to point fingers, many point at Blair Walsh. Expected but not warranted.
Social media provides everyone with a unique platform for free, unfiltered expression, often at the expense of respect. Admittedly, for example, it’s convenient for a person to tweet “Blair Walsh is the worst kicker I’ve ever seen… smh #choke” in the safety of his house two thousand miles away from the game.
This ease of typing, clicking, and posting sometimes allows people to bypass or neglect a key stage of reflection: “I wouldn’t say that to him in person, but I’m posting it on social media, so it’s okay.” Sure, a clear barrier exists between the online critic and the subject of the criticism, but the vitriol of the words nonetheless makes an impact.
Let’s say Walsh missed the field goal in the first quarter and later went on to score his nine points. Let’s say Minnesota Vikings running back Adrian Peterson fumbled the football (which led to a scoring Seattle Seahawks drive) after Walsh missed the field goal. Would people criticize Walsh as harshly as they did before? What if the Vikings played better defense? What if the weather was better? These hypotheticals and variables suggest that the blame of a significant loss cannot fall on one person’s shoulders. The beauty, or blemish, of competitive team sports is that, win or lose, all individuals – coaches, players, trainers – play a role in the outcome of a season.
After all is said and done, when people toss enough insults into the cloud of social media, these remarks eventually fall upon an actual person. Blair Walsh made a mistake. It’s time to move on.