Islamophobic ignorance
Violence in Muslim countries recently catapulted into headlines after political commentator Bill Maher spoke of the issue in a tone reminiscent of a charged (and unsubstantiated) Youtube comment.
Without a doubt, there are systems in place within certain Muslim countries that are horrifying, sexist and alarmingly violent. But these systems corrupt and poison the fundamental messages Islam imparts — peace, faith and the equality of all men in the eyes of God.
To clarify, I am not Muslim, and to be honest, I’m not sure what religion I would classify myself as. But all religions, at their cores, provide an ethical code for individuals to act in accordance with, in order to bring balance and stability to communities. The interpretation of balance, of course, can become problematic — for example, Hinduism’s insistence upon the caste system or Christianity’s assertion that women should “submit [them]selves unto [their] husbands” Ephesians 5:22.
All religions can be distorted to validate power imbalances. But this is not the singularly defining feature of religion.
The actions and beliefs of ISIS define Islam in the same context that the Ku Klux Klan defines Christianity. Even a religion as theoretically peace oriented as Buddhism has paved the pathway for violent extremism, such as attacks against the Rohingya Muslims in Myanmar.
Indonesia has a larger Muslim population than Afghanistan, Syria and Saudi Arabia combined. Yet, individuals condemning the violent tendencies of “Muslim countries” choose to ignore the likes of Indonesia, Malaysia and Turkey in their assessments of Islam’s role in perpetuating violent societies.
The selective ignorance these individuals brandish as they proclaim their denunciation of one of the world’s most prominent religions is potentially one of the most harmful attitudes the media can sustain. They choose to ignore facts in favor of personal anecdotes and prejudices, and this position lands firmly within the grounds of Islamophobia. The Taliban, Al Quaeda, ISIS — these organizations are not synecdoches for Islam, and saying that they are is fundamentally bigoted.
One of the primary issues these individuals address is that of female genital mutilation (FGM).
In Somalia, a dominantly Muslim country, 98% of females undergo FGM. Its predominantly Christian neighbor Ethiopia has a 75% rate of FGM. Towards the western side of the African continent, females in Niger, a country consisting of 94% Muslims, experience FGM at a rate of approximately 2%.
For the purpose of this example, the United States could hypothetically be conceived as a Christian state — the dollar bill proclaims our trust in God, and much of the political debate in this country revolves around what the Bible deems appropriate.
When the United States decides to invade a country, its violent actions are not characterized by Christianity. When Somalian citizens genitally mutilate an overwhelming majority of the country’s females, their actions should not be characterized by Islam, but rather by the regional culture that deems FGM acceptable.
FGM is prevalent in certain Muslim countries, just as it is within certain Christian countries. Religion is not the underlying factor.
By the same token, several of the practices in more violent Muslim countries are arguably more influenced by politics and societal trends than religion; many religious practices even in these countries, now enforced by law, stem from traditions even preceding the advent of Islam.
For instance, while the Quran states that “the Best garment is that of nice, modest conduct” 7:26 , it never explicitly demands that women wear a hijab. The practice of women veiling themselves evolved from adaptations of Byzantine culture and Zoroastrianism.
Selective ignorance when addressing these issues, particularly amongst voices in the media as prominent as CNN and Bill Maher, encourages Islamophobia in the United States. Several countries around the globe, ranging from Yemen to Russia, are systematically ratifying violence and oppression. Several of those countries, such as Saudi Arabia and Somalia, are predominantly Muslim. But we cannot ignore the fact that several of them are not, nor can we ignore the fact that several “Muslim countries” have taken steps towards gender equality that the United States has not.
Bangladesh, the third most populous majority Muslim country, has elected female heads of state Khaleda Zia and Sheikh Hasina to serve for a combined 20-year period. In 2010, 27.7% of Afghanistan’s Parliament seats were held by women. Women consist of only 18.5% of the United States Congress today.
Contrary to what Bill Maher may think, Islam is not a “problem,” and the issues he claims derive from the religion cannot be solved by the ignorant assumptions he makes about 1.5 billion people on national television.