Review: Taylor Swift lets down fans with new pop album – 3.5/5 stars
October 23, 2012
Country-pop singer Taylor Swift disappointed her die-hard fans with the new pop-rock tunes in Red, her fourth album, which was released on October 22.
Swift’s latest album leans towards the pop side of the music spectrum and nearly obliterates the country roots that fans have come to love. Almost all of the songs featured on Red consist of an annoying, heavy pop beat, with almost no sign of her trademark acoustic guitar. Though the style and substance of her lyrics remain the same, it is clear that Swift is outgrowing country music.
Both relatable and bluntly honest, Swift’s lyrics are the best feature of her new album. She continues to describe the ups and downs of love, something every individual is able to empathize with. Even though they are lacking in complexity, the lyrics of Red still touch the hearts of listeners.
While Swift has made changes to her actual music, she continues her custom of including secret messages in each song of her album. Swift capitalizes letters in the lyrics section of her album booklet in the hopes that a listener will string all the uppercase letters together and discover the hidden words. The secret message of “We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together” is “When I stopped caring about what you thought,” leaving fans to speculate about whom it is written about.
The best song from this album is “Sad Beautiful Tragic,” because it still retains the qualities that Swift used to develop her own original identity; elements of country music are detectable, along with the sense of calm usually associated with her music. Her old fans will still be able to listen to a glimpse of the country version of Swift. “Sad Beautiful Tragic,” resembles songs featured on Swift’s second album, Fearless, which was released in 2008.
Other impressive songs in Red include “Treacherous” and “The Last Time,” a collaboration she worked on with Gary Lightbody, who is the lead singer of the band Snow Patrol. Swift’s duets with Lightbody and Ed Sheeran add an element of alternative rock to her album. However, even though many fans of Swift may love her upbeat and catchy tunes, country music fans will find the majority of her new songs to be a step down from her previous work.
Although many fans may prefer Swift’s older albums, they are still eagerly awaiting the release of the Red tour dates, which will be announced on her website shortly.