Legendary playoff runs define careers.
Fans remember postseason moments and banners in stadiums over extraordinary statistics. Former New York Giants franchise quarterback Eli Manning exemplifies this theory. Manning etched his name in the annals of NFL history by defeating Tom Brady and the nigh-invincible Patriots twice in the Super Bowl. Now, Manning faces the toughest challenge of his career thus far: gaining first-ballot entry into the Pro Football Hall of Fame.
A variety of factors go into being immortalized in the NFL’s museum in Canton, complicating matters for the former Giants star. Manning’s older brother, Peyton, is among the greatest quarterbacks of all time, having earned a number of impressive accolades, including his own first-ballot entry into the Hall of Fame in 2021. His career serves as an effective comparison to Eli’s, representing what a first-ballot Hall of Fame quarterback should be.
By contrast, Eli’s resume looks lackluster, with only four Pro Bowl appearances to Peyton’s 14 and zero first team All-Pro selections to Peyton’s seven. Peyton holds the league record for MVPs with five, an accolade his younger brother never accrued. Eli never led the league in a major statistical category, a fact that underscores his low peak in the regular season.
With all that said, Manning’s poor case for first-ballot Hall of Fame entry does not minimize his achievements. He remains a significant figure in NFL history and should make the Hall at some point. After all, he boasts incredible numbers, ranking 10th on the list for all-time passing yards and passing touchdowns. At the same time, one must take into account the era of inflated offense that he benefited from, a phenomenon that inflated the resume of many 2010s quarterbacks.
That spark, though, does not automatically qualify him for the Hall and quite possibly comes as a product of his opponents. Manning owes a large portion of his brand to Tom Brady. Having defeated Brady’s Patriots twice, Manning appears much greater to fans, exacerbating the controversy surrounding his entry into the Hall.
Since his retirement, Manning has remained a fan favorite, appearing in several popular football programs, often alongside his brother. Unfortunately for Manning, neither popularity nor his aforementioned postseason success grants him entry into the Hall. Before he reaches the mountaintop of personal achievement in the sport, he will have to wait.