“The Giver” is an unsatisfactory adaptation of Lois Lowry’s Classic Novel – 2.5/5

Fans of Lois Lowry's novel "The Giver" will be disappointed by the movie adaptation, which is neither memorable nor completely true to the original storyline.
IMDbFans of Lois Lowry’s novel “The Giver” will be disappointed by the movie adaptation, which is neither memorable nor completely true to the original storyline. 
 

Directed by Phillip Noyce, the film “The Giver” is yet another addition to the young adult dystopian fiction genre. The movie is interesting to watch and features great visual effects and a star-studded cast but fails to leave viewers wanting more due to the movie’s plot and intent straying too much from the original book by Lois Lowry.

Both the movie and book focus on the protagonist named Jonas, played by Brenton Thwaites, who lives in a dystopian society. In this society, all people are forced to be the exact same as everyone else in a world with no feelings, colors, or social hierarchy due to the conflict caused by these elements. Jonas is assigned to be the Receiver of Memory, the one person in the community who will get memories of how life was like with colors and feelings from the Giver. The movie follows Jonas as he receives memories and his perspective of the world changes.

The visual effects of the movie include the movie starting out in black and white before slowly changing into color as Jonas receives memories. Along with the dynamic visual effects, the actors also helped depict the repressive nature of the dystopian society with startling detail; members of the cast include Meryl Streep, Jeff Bridges, Taylor Swift, and Alexander Skarsgard. However, the excellent effects and skill of the actors were overshadowed by the movie’s flaws.

The first difference between the book and the movie is the fact that Jonas is 11 in the book but 18 in the movie. Since Jonas is much older, the movie also includes a romantic aspect that is not present in the book. Also, there is an action scene and chase added at the end of the movie as Jonas is trying to escape the society that he lives in. Adding the romance and action scenes make the story stray from the intention of Lowry’s book; the movie starts to resemble the “Hunger Games” or “Divergent” when the story is meant to be a children’s classic not an action-packed teen romance novel.

“The Giver” retains most of the plot details of the book but fails to convey these details in a meaningful way on screen. Despite its flaws, the film earned a 7.1/10 on IMDb and a B+ on Cinemascore, but other critics were not as generous. Metascore gave the movie a 46/100 and Rotten Tomatoes gave the film a “rotten” rating of 32 percent. “The Giver” was entertaining to watch but could not live up to the expectations of Lowry’s classic novel; the movie became just another generic addition to the young adult genre.